Maria Rigo exercising using dumb bell

Why More Exercise Isn't Always Better After 50

November 04, 2026•4 min read

Have you ever added more exercise to your routine because you weren't getting the results you wanted, only to end up feeling more tired, sore, or frustrated?

Maybe you thought you needed to work harder, add another workout, or push yourself a little more.

I see this quite often with women over 50, especially women who are also managing Hashimoto's.

And I get it. When you're not seeing the changes you want, it's easy to think the answer is to do more.

But sometimes, doing more is exactly what you don't need.

When Exercise Leaves You Feeling Worse

I worked with one woman who came to me frustrated. She had Hashimoto's and was exercising more in an effort to get results. But instead of feeling stronger, she'd often end up hurting or completely exhausted.

She was putting in the effort. She just wasn't getting the results she wanted.

We changed the type of exercise she was doing, incorporated MELT and MELT NeuroStrength, and worked on changing her approach to eating.

Over time, she noticed a difference. One of my favorite ways to describe her progress? She no longer needed the rubber-band extender around the snap of her jeans.

It was a little thing, but it was a real change she could see and feel.

And it didn't come from pushing harder. It came from finding a different approach.

Your Workout Should Challenge You, Not Wipe You Out

Now, I'm not saying exercise should always feel easy. Building strength takes effort, and challenging your muscles is important.

But there's a difference between challenging your body and constantly pushing it beyond what it can recover from.

As we get older, our bodies and our needs can change. Add in Hashimoto's, fluctuating energy, joint issues, stress, or poor sleep, and the workout that used to work for you may not be the best fit anymore.

That doesn't mean you need to stop exercising. It may mean you need to rethink what you're doing.

Here are a few things I'd encourage you to consider:

  • Are you doing the right kind of exercise? More cardio isn't necessarily the answer. Strength training is important for maintaining and building muscle as we age.

  • Are you allowing enough recovery? If you're constantly sore, exhausted, or struggling to get through your workouts, it may be time to look at your intensity and frequency.

  • Are you paying attention to how your body feels? You don't have to push through every ache or ignore signs that something isn't working.

  • Are you progressing at a pace that makes sense for you? You don't have to keep up with someone else's workout or fitness level.

If exercise consistently leaves you feeling worse, it's worth stepping back and reassessing your routine. Persistent pain, unusual exhaustion, or new symptoms deserve attention from your healthcare provider, too.

Sometimes a Different Approach Is What You Need

I've lived with Hashimoto's for more than 30 years. I know firsthand that figuring out what works for your body can take time.

As I approach 60, I feel stronger and have more energy than I did in my 20s. That didn't happen by doing more of everything. It came from learning to listen to my body, adjusting my approach, and finding ways to build strength and take care of myself that fit my life.

That's also how I approach coaching.

Through Strong After 50, I help women figure out where they are, what their bodies need, and how to move forward without feeling like they have to follow another rigid plan.

It's one of the things we work on inside the [Strong After 50 Collective](INSERT YOUR SALES PAGE LINK). It's a place for women to get guidance, learn, build strength, and make changes that work in real life.

You don't have to exercise harder just because you're over 50 and not getting the results you want.

Sometimes the better question isn't, "How can I do more?"

It's, "What would actually help my body get stronger?"


About Maria

Maria helps women 50+ lose weight, build muscle, improve energy and sleep, and reduce aches and pains so they can live active, healthy lives long term. Her work focuses on building muscle safely and keeping blood sugar steady.

Back to Blog