
Why Healthy Habits After 50 Are Hard to Stick With
Lasting change isn't just about knowing what to do. It's about becoming the woman who follows through.
If you've been following me for a while, you've heard me talk about looking at your health differently as you move through your 50s and beyond. Your body is changing, and the things that worked for you 20 or 30 years ago may not work the same way now.
We've talked about nutrition, building muscle, movement, recovery, stress and learning to listen to what your body is telling you. And all of those things matter.
But there's another piece that I don't want you to overlook.
What happens when you know what to do... and you still don't do it?
Because I've worked with women for 25 years, and I've seen this over and over again.
They're smart. They're capable. They care about their health. They've tried the diets, bought the programs, joined the gyms, added the protein and promised themselves that this time would be different.
And sometimes it is — for a while.
Then life happens.
Maybe they get busy. Maybe everyone else's needs move to the top of the list. Maybe they lose motivation. Maybe they have a glass of wine and pizza and decide they've blown it.
And eventually they're back to wondering, “Why can't I just stick with it?”
I've heard that question so many times.
I've even had women say to me, “I wish I had your discipline,” or “You're so determined. I don't know how you do it.”
Can I tell you a secret?
It's not because I'm special.
I learned something about myself a long time ago that changed the way I approach health — and it changed the way I coach women, too.
Lasting change doesn't start with trying harder.
It starts with understanding what's happening underneath the behavior.
Why Knowing What to Do Isn't Enough
Let me give you an example.
Imagine I have a book that contains everything you need to know to create a healthy, joyful life. It covers your health, your relationships, your mindset, your habits and your choices.
I give that same book to two women.
One woman opens it immediately. She reads it, takes notes, starts applying what she's learning and keeps coming back to it.
The other woman puts it on a shelf. She thinks, “I'll get to it when I have more time.”
They both have the same information.
But who do you think is more likely to create a different life?
The woman who uses the information.
And yet, this is what we often do with our health.
We decide we're going to “get healthy,” stop having the nightly glass of wine, start exercising again, eat more protein or finally take better care of ourselves.
And we do it.
For a week.
Maybe a month.
Maybe even a year.
But then something changes.
So what's going on?
The problem isn't necessarily that you don't know what to do. Research on behavior change supports something many of us have experienced firsthand: knowing that a behavior is good for us doesn't automatically make it easy to maintain. Creating lasting change involves understanding our patterns, dealing with roadblocks and continuing through setbacks.
So let's look at what may be happening underneath the behavior.
Your Subconscious Patterns May Be Running the Show
We take in an enormous amount of information through our senses every day. Our conscious mind can only pay attention to a fraction of it, so our brains are constantly filtering and organizing what gets our attention.
Over time, we also develop patterns of thinking and responding based on our experiences.
Some of those patterns serve us.
Some don't.
And some of them are so familiar that we don't even recognize them as patterns anymore.
They're just “the way I am.”
Maybe you tell yourself:
“I've never been good at sticking with things.”
“I'm just not disciplined.”
“I always fall off.”
“I don't have enough time.”
“I've already tried everything.”
“I'm too old to change this now.”
Or maybe you've become so good at taking care of everyone else that taking care of yourself feels like something you have to squeeze in when everything else is done.
Here's what I want you to hear:
You may have learned these patterns, but that doesn't mean you have to keep living from them.
That's why I say so often, you're not broken, and it's not your fault.
But that doesn't mean you're powerless.
There is a difference.
You can learn to notice the pattern. You can question the story. And you can begin choosing something different.
That's where change starts.
Why I Stopped Relying on Accountability Alone
I've been helping women for 25 years, and early in my work I noticed something that bothered me.
I'd have a client who was showing up, working hard, investing in herself and making progress. As long as we were working together closely, she was doing great.
But when I wasn't there holding her accountable?
She'd start to “fall off.”
I could have blamed it on motivation.
I could have told her she needed more discipline.
But that didn't make sense to me.
These were smart, capable women who genuinely wanted to feel better.
So I started asking a different question:
Why would a woman who wants change so badly keep returning to the same patterns?
That question took me deeper into the work of the mind and eventually into NLP, or Neuro-Linguistic Programming.
You don't have to be “woo” to understand this.
You just have to have a mind.
The way we talk to ourselves matters. The stories we carry matter. The beliefs we've developed about ourselves matter. And when those things are running in the background, they can influence the choices we make without us even realizing it.
That's when I stopped thinking my job was simply to hold women accountable.
I wanted to help them understand why they were struggling to follow through in the first place.
Lasting Change Starts With More Than Behavior
When we want to change something, we usually start at the bottom.
We clean out the kitchen.
We buy a new workout program.
We sign up for a class.
We change what we're eating.
We start walking.
And there's nothing wrong with any of those things.
But they're only part of the picture.
I use a framework that looks at the different levels underneath our behavior:
Purpose → Identity → Values & Beliefs → Capabilities → Behavior → Environment
Most health programs start with behavior and environment.
Change your food.
Change your workout.
Change your surroundings.
And those things can absolutely help.
But I want you to work from the top down, too.
Because if your goal is to lose weight, but underneath that you believe you're someone who “never follows through,” that's going to matter.
If you want to get stronger, but you believe you're “too old” or “not athletic,” that's going to matter.
If you want to take better care of yourself, but your identity has been built around being the person who takes care of everyone else first, that's going to matter.
This is why I don't just hand women a plan and tell them to follow it.
We work on the woman who is going to live the plan.
Who Are You Becoming?
Instead of only asking:
“What do I need to do?”
I want you to start asking:
“Who am I becoming?”
What do you want your health to allow you to do?
Who do you want to be in this next chapter of your life?
What matters enough to you that you're willing to keep choosing it, even when life gets busy?
And what beliefs are you carrying that may no longer be serving the woman you're becoming?
This is where I see the biggest shift happen with my clients.
We don't just create another list of things you're supposed to do.
We slow down.
We get honest.
We notice the patterns.
We uncover the stories underneath them.
And then we start making different choices from a different place.
One small choice.
Then another.
And another.
That's how you begin to build evidence for a new identity.
A recent client said something that really stuck with me:
“It's not as hard as I used to think it should be. Take one small step, then another. They start to add up and you start feeling fantastic.”
That's it.
Not perfection.
Not doing everything right.
Not waiting until you're motivated.
One small step. Then another.
Your Body and Your Mind Have to Work Together
This is also why my approach to health is different.
I don't believe you have to choose between working on your body and working on your mind.
We need both.
Your body needs strength. It needs nourishing food. It needs movement. It needs recovery. And as we age, maintaining and building muscle becomes especially important for strength, physical function and independence.
But your mind matters, too.
Because you can know exactly how important strength training is and still struggle to make yourself do it consistently.
You can know what foods make you feel better and still find yourself eating in a way that doesn't support you.
You can know you need more sleep and still stay up late because there are ten other things you want to get done.
That's not a knowledge problem.
That's where we need to look at the patterns underneath the behavior.
And that's where I bring together the physical and psychological sides of health.
We work on your body, but we also work on your relationship with your body.
We work on strength, nutrition, movement and recovery, while also paying attention to stress, self-talk, beliefs and the subconscious patterns that may be keeping you stuck.
Because lasting change isn't about forcing yourself to become someone you're not.
It's about becoming more aware of who you are, what you need and what matters to you — and then practicing choices that support that woman.
What Lasting Change Actually Looks Like
This is the part I wish more women understood.
Lasting change isn't necessarily dramatic.
It doesn't always look like losing 30 pounds or completely transforming your body.
Sometimes it looks like realizing you don't need to start over every Monday.
Sometimes it's getting through a stressful week without abandoning yourself.
Sometimes it's choosing the workout that supports your body instead of punishing it.
Sometimes it's eating a nourishing meal because you want to feel good, not because you were “bad” yesterday.
Sometimes it's going to bed instead of staying up to finish one more thing.
Sometimes it's keeping a small promise to yourself.
And every time you do that, you're creating new evidence.
I can trust myself.
I can follow through.
I can take care of myself.
That's the deeper transformation.
Yes, the physical changes matter.
Getting stronger matters.
Changing your body composition matters.
Having more energy matters.
Sleeping better matters.
Feeling better in your clothes matters.
But what happens when those changes are accompanied by a completely different relationship with yourself?
That's when things start to feel different.
You're not constantly looking for the next plan.
You're not waiting for someone else to tell you what to do.
You're not starting over every Monday.
You're becoming the woman who knows how to take care of herself.
You Don't Have to Spend the Next Decade Starting Over
If you're reading this and thinking, “Okay, Maria. I know what I want to do. I just want to finally make it stick,” I want you to know that this is exactly the kind of work we do together.
Inside the Strong After 50 Collective, we don't just focus on workouts.
We work on building strength, supporting your health and creating the mindset and habits that allow you to keep showing up for yourself.
You'll have guidance, community and a place to ask questions when you're not sure what to do next.
And more importantly, you'll have a place to practice becoming the woman who follows through.
The woman who moves her body consistently.
The woman who honors her needs without guilt.
The woman who builds strength for the years ahead.
The woman who trusts herself.
You don't need to have it all figured out before you begin.
You don't need another perfect plan.
You just need to be willing to take the next step.
You don't need to become a different person.
You need to start uncovering the woman who's already there.
JOIN THE STRONG AFTER 50 COLLECTIVE
I'll see you inside.
About Maria
Maria helps women 50+ lose weight, build muscle, improve energy and sleep, and reduce aches and pains so they can live active, healthy lives long term. Her work focuses on building muscle safely and keeping blood sugar steady.